Why did Leeds United sack Jesse Marsch? Premier League club fires American manager amidst poor form

American coach Jesse Marsch is out as manager of Leeds United after less than a year in charge.

The 49-year-old took over at the Premier League club after the dismissal of Marcelo Bielsa in late February, 2022. At the time, Marsch was considered an apt replacement due to his European success at RB Salzburg and his deployment of a high-press tactical approach that fit with Bielsa’s style, lending to a seamless transition from one coach to the other.

While Marsch saved the club from relegation last season, poor form through the winter of the 2022/23 campaign has seen the club back in the fight near the bottom of the table.

Ultimately, the poor results and relegation possibility have led to Marsch’s dismissal, but some things don’t quite add up amidst the long-term project of the club.

MORE: Next Premier League manager to be sacked odds

Leeds United form under Jesse Marsch

It’s tough to spin an argument defending Jesse Marsch when you consider the recent form of Leeds United in Premier League play.

Marsch started the year by picking up eight points from the first five matches of the season through the end of August, but since, the club has won just twice and collected just nine points.

Leeds have suffered a host of difficult defeats in recent weeks, coming close to securing results but unable to get over the hump. They drew 0-0 with both Newcastle and Brentford, clubs that would have expected to beat the relegation contenders, and suffered a 2-1 defeat to Aston Villa that saw them miss a host of chances in front of net. The latest result, a 1-0 loss to Nottingham Forest, came as Leeds again failed to finish a number of good opportunities, stymied by new Forest goalkeeper Keylor Navas.

Away form under Marsch has been particularly poor, even from the start, as Leeds have picked up just five points from 10 road league matches this season. In fact, Marsch’s struggles on the road date back to before he joined the Premier League club. Since leaving RB Salzburg to join RB Leipzig in 2021, Marsch has picked up just four wins in 23 road games across all competitions with RB Leipzig and Leeds, collecting six draws while suffering 13 defeats.

5 – Leeds United have lost each of their last five Premier League away games against teams starting the day in the bottom half of the table, their longest ever such run in the competition. Submissive. pic.twitter.com/f4cyxKYP68

— OptaJoe (@OptaJoe) February 5, 2023

Finishing a big issue for Leeds United

While Marsch’s tactical approach has failed to produce results, it can be harsh to place that blame squarely on his shoulders.

Recently, Leeds have suffered from a run of extremely poor finishing in front of goal, which has cost them points. That was on full display in the recent 1-0 defeat to Nottingham Forest that ultimately sealed Marsch’s fate, with Keylor Navas making a host of big saves and Patrick Bamford putting forth a horrible effort on a 34th minute shot that should have found the back of the net.

What I’m saying is that if Patrick Bamford makes his sitter yesterday, I doubt we’re having this news cycle today.

Such is management at the highest levels. Fine margins all around.

— Jeff Rueter (@jeffrueter) February 6, 2023

While Leeds’ overall season expected goals mark of 27.53 xG sports just a negligible -1.53 differential from xG to actual goals scored, they have fallen short in key moments that have cost them points in matches throughout the season where they dominated play but failed to come away with a result. For example, the defeat to Nottingham Forest saw Leeds fall 1-0 despite owning a 1.12-0.33 xG advantage. Again this occurred in the 2-1 defeat to Aston Villa where they won the xG battle 2.46-1.64, or a 1-0 defeat to league leaders Arsenal where they finished the match with a massive 2.02-0.82 xG advantage.

This is reflected when evaluating the league based on Expected Points, which is an analytical statistic which generates a number between zero and three for the amount of points a team should have collected based on the scoring chances of each match. According to UnderStat.com, Leeds United’s xPTS value of 25.87 sees them hold a -7.87 differential from actual points to expected points, second-worst in the league behind West Ham’s -11.35. On xPTS, Leeds would sit 12th in the league, a full five places higher than their actual position of 17th.

Again, this concept is evident when you review the way in which Leeds have fallen short this season, losing seven one-goal matches this year, one of the worst marks in the Premier League.

Leeds this PL season…

⚽ 17th in the table, out of relegation zone on goal difference

⚽ Tied for 13th in goal difference (-8)

⚽ 12th in expected goal difference (-3.1)

⚽ 3 wins, 7 losses in games decided by exactly one goal (3rd-worst win pct in PL)

— Paul Carr (@PaulCarr) February 6, 2023

While Marsch can be blamed for some of the defensive mistakes and tactical slips, the underlying numbers (and simply watching the matches) suggest the players have also let him down greatly in front of goal.

Marsch transfer activity at Leeds United

While it’s hard to defend Marsch based simply on results, it’s also extremely confusing why Leeds have taken this step now, just six days after the end of the January transfer window.

Marsch’s philosophy and tactical approach were key to the Leeds transfer strategy this past winter, where the club spent €41 million on incoming players. Max Wober cost the club €12 million, arriving from RB Salzburg, a former Marsch coaching stop, and was clearly a target to fit his coaching style. Additionally, Leeds acquired American international Weston McKennie on Deadline Day, with the midfielder reportedly swayed to join the club on loan from Juventus by Marsch himself.

Leeds buying all those player’s that suits Marsch idea & philosophy just to sack him after 1 game!

— Prosper Bartalomew (@prosperbartha) February 6, 2023

Widen the lens to include the previous summer transfer window, and this decision gets even more baffling. €32 million arrival Brenden Aaronson is essentially the combination of the two aforementioned winter acquisitions: an American international arriving from RB Salzburg, a disciple of the Red Bull pressing system. American midfielder Tyler Adams is another pressing whiz, and he has excelled in the Marsch high-press system.

It’s enormously confusing why the club would turn around and bail on Marsch just days — and indeed, months — after the significant financial investment in players that would fit his style of play going forward.

GAMING SURVEY: Complete short survey for chance to win international football shirt of your choice!